Why I love these (not so) Final Fantasies
Final Fantasy XIII is launching next week, and I’m geeking out like a six year old waiting for Christmas. It’s amazing how I still anticipate the launch of an FF game. My age, my few years in the games industry, my bitterness about sequelitis and the popularity of the FPS have beaten down the excitement I generally feel about game launches. I’m a skeptic, at times even a cynic, about The Next Big Thing™. But when Square Enix see fit to unleash a new numbered Final Fantasy title upon the world, my negativity dissolves and I turn into the same raging fanboy I was in July of 1991, 11 years old, begging my parents to take me to Toys R Us to buy Final Fantasy IV.
I hear a lot of hate for the FF games in this business. Maybe it’s just the people I surround myself with (I seem to have a knack for landing jobs with PC-centric, FPS-loving studios), but I usually feel like the odd man out for loving these games, and I really have trouble understanding where the hate comes from. I’ll admit, they’re not the deepest games ever made. Their stories are pretty linear, they don’t give you much choice, their art style tends to borrow a lot from the previous games and there’s LOTS of story, mostly told through cinematics. But I’m willing to forgive these elements. Why?
When I pick up a new, numbered Final Fantasy game (as opposed to the numerous spinoffs), there are a handful of things I can always count on:
An Amazing World
The FF games always have fantastic worlds. Beautiful, lush environments with lots of variety. Stunning visuals, amazing lighting and effects, a deep back story, creative architecture, wild character and creature designs and a general dislike of the mundane all make their worlds interesting places to explore. They’re not realistic, but who cares? I’m playing a video game. I don’t want realism.
Attention to Detail
The experience is always strong, and you can tell that the developers pore over every detail with a fine-toothed comb. Nothing is broken or alpha in a FF game. Everything gets its final polish. I’ve read that one of the big motivators for the removal of towns in FF13 was the concern that they didn’t have the time or resources to deliver them at the level of quality they wanted. So they cut them rather than ship something below par.
A Well-Written Story
The stories of Final Fantasy sometimes wander, but they always come together by the end. Despite the melodramatic dialogue, annoying characters (Squall ffs), weird plot turns and dead ends, they always deliver by the time the credits roll. There’s something to be said for this. Most games can’t manage to keep my interest for eight hours, but FF games can consistently hold me in their grasp for 40+ (and 120 in the case of FF12), and this is due in large part to an interesting story. And yes, there are those cinematics. Some gamers despise them, but I’ve never been bothered by them. I’m not a purist, my games don’t have to be ALL game and nothing else. I’m content to be passive for a while and watch, as long as what I’m watching is interesting.
Bang for Buck
As mentioned above, I spent 120 hours working my way through Final Fantasy 12. That was spread over two years, because I was quite busy with work. Generally they take 40-50 hours, but still, that’s a hell of a lot better than most games these days. Batman: Arkham Asylum was a solid eight hours, which comes out to $7.50 per hour. Final Fantasy games are generally in the $1 per hour range, and the gameplay and story are more interesting, at least to me, than the majority of AAA releases these days. I know they will deliver a game that’s going to entertain me for a long, long time.
Nostalgia
The Final Fantasy games know where they came from. They’re always full of fan service, and their fans appreciate it. Recurring characters, themes, types of environments… some accuse them of failing to innovate, but I disagree and point you to their battle systems for proof of innovation. There are always chocobos, summons and a guy named Cid. It’s nice to know that, despite being thrown into a new world with new characters, environments and systems, you can count on a few familiar faces to be there by your side.
Innovation
The FF games have always excelled at experimenting wildly within the confines of a formula they know works (and occasionally creeping outside the lines just a little bit). The draw system of FF8, the MMO-style gameplay of FF12, the broken as hell Materia system of FF7 and the job system of FF5 are all examples. While they’re all JRPGs and remain true to the style, they always bring something new to the table.
I wonder if the negativity aimed at this franchise by some western developers is truly a dislike of the game style, or simply envy. A Final Fantasy game is always a big budget affair with a mind-blowing level of polish and attention to detail, and their effort is rewarded in critical acclaim and sales. XIII currently has a GameRankings average of 82.9% (PS3 version), making it one of the lowest scores ever in the main franchise. Some devs may hate these games, but when 83% is your low point in a franchise that has spanned thirteen titles so far, I’d say you’re doing something very, very right.